Nutritional Approaches for Depression
The main treatments used for depression tend to be anti-depressant drugs and counselling. However other approaches, including nutrition, can make a real difference and often get overlooked. Few people realise how much impact good nutrition has on our mental state.
Studies of Food on Mood
Sir Robert McCarrison in the 1930s worked with rats whilst studying what made people live longer. He fed rats the diet of the Hunzas, an isolated community with exceptionally good health who ate a natural diet, he fed another group of rats the typical British diet at the time, giving them white bread, sugar, boiled vegetables, tinned food and he also fed some rats on the Southern Indian diet (these races had poor health). The results were unequivocal: those on the Hunza diet had no disease and lived long healthy lives. But there was something else. These rats were cheerful, easily handled and lived harmoniously together. Those on the British and Southern Indian diets developed diseases of the lung and stomach, had stunted growth, poor coats and lived shorter lives. But psychologically they were also different. They were nervous and quarrelsome; they bit their attendants and eventually killed off and ate weaker members of their group. There can be no clearer demonstration on the effect food has on our well being.
A recent study from the University of Leeds and York of 45,000 people gave incredible results. They found each extra portion of fruit and vegetable eaten added to mental well-being and life satisfaction.
Both the quantity and frequency of fruit and vegetables eaten contributed to mental well-being. This is a great way to improve your mental health because it does something else as well; it boosts physical health and immunity at the same time.
Other studies back this up. A study of people using a plant-based diet at 10 locations in the USA found improvements in mood, daily well-being, anxiety and depression.
A study of 3000 Canadians found that those eating more fruit and vegetables had less anxiety and depression and an American study showed the same dose-response benefit from fruit and vegetables noted at the University of Leeds and York. In other words the higher the intake of fruit and vegetable the better the mood and the lower the risk of depression.
Another study was done on men and women who ate meat once daily. After stopping meat, eggs and dairy for two weeks they experienced a significant improvement in their moods.
Studies of prisoners and young offenders have shown giving multivitamins and essential fats reduced aggression markedly. Cross country studies have shown that the nations that eat the most fish have the lowest rates of depression. Omega 3 fats – found mainly in oily fish, have been shown to reduce depression and aggression. In six trials of omega 3 fats in depression, five showed significant improvements, including in patients resistant to standard anti-depressants. The improvement was around 50% (compared with 15% for anti-depressant drugs). Omega 3 fats have also been found to improve sleep, increase libido and reduce thoughts that life is not worth living.
Coffee drinkers, having two cups daily had half the suicide risk compared to non-coffee drinkers and those who had 6 cups daily were 80% less likely to be suicidal.
Eating oily fish such as mackerel, herrings, anchovies and sardines increase Omega 3 fats. Farmed salmon is not recommended as it has less Omega 3 fats and is high in toxic chemicals. EPA fish oils are also widely available at health food stores. Fish oils contain 2 key substances known as EPA and DHA – ideally use a fish oil which gives 1 gram daily of EPA as this is the key component for helping depression (DHA has no effect on depression).
Diet really works for mental health. Eat as many natural foods as possible –fruit, vegetables, wholegrains, seeds, nuts and oily fish. Avoid processed food with its high load of sugar, salt and adulterated fats.
This sweetener, which is found in diet drinks, and in over 6000 products and processed foods, deserves a special mention. Aspartame blocks the conversion of tryptophan to serotonin (see later).
Initial studies at Case Western Reserve University were stopped abruptly because aspartame caused severe reactions in patients with a history of depression. Later studies have found people without mental health problems became depressed and irritable within a week of taking higher doses of aspartame (equivalent to 3 litres of Diet Coke) an on a daily basis. In other words if you are depressed avoid aspartame.
Drugs and Depression
One study found those taking three pharmaceutical drugs had 3 times the incidence of depression. Danish studies have found that those taking the contraceptive pill take 70% more antidepressant drugs and those between 15 and 19 taking the pill have double the amount of depression found in those not on the pill.
There’s another important food factor that promotes depression and that’s a fluctuating blood sugar levels. This is caused by a diet high in sugar (typical of the modern diet). In one study 92% of patients with anxiety had blood sugar problems with low sugar at certain times. Episodes of low sugar cause adrenaline release and this can makes people feel more anxious. The average person takes in over 30 teaspoonfuls of sugar daily, mostly in processed foods.
If you eat too much sugar or white flour or other refined carbohydrates then your sugar levels will be unstable, going up and down. Many people don’t realise how much better they can feel simply by cutting sugar out of their diet or at least avoiding high sugar foods such as biscuits, cakes, cereals, yoghurts and most processed foods. But beware there is sugar in almost everything – read the labels. Anything ending in –“ose” or “ol” –sucrose, lactose, fructose is a sugar – and probably the worst sugar of all is high fructose corn syrup as it is absorbed so rapidly than the body can hardly tolerate it. Top of the list of foods is to cut out are fizzy drinks and squashes which can have up to 8 teaspoonfuls of sugar in. One study found people who drank more fizzy or sugary drinks had 30% more depression. It might be tempting to use chemical sweeteners instead but these only maintains a desire for sugar and have been shown to promote obesity –it is better to just cut the sugars out –after a while everything will taste better.
Remember that the body needs B vitamins and chromium to turn every teaspoonful of sugar into energy and these rapidly become depleted on a high sugar diet or with alcohol. Having a diet that cuts out these sugars can help some types of depression. So can taking B vitamins. A study by a Dr McLeod who gave 600mcg of chromium to people suffering from depression found they had a 83% drop on the HRS scale and a follow-up trial showed a 65% improvement. Note chromium is the substance that is refined out of sugar and white flour.
Most anti-depressant drugs act by increasing the levels of serotonin (sometimes known as the happy chemical) and sometimes noradrenalin (the motivating chemical) in the brain. These drugs, called SSRIs, have been shown to decrease depression in some people. Improvements in depression are normally measured on the Hamilton Rating Scale (HRS) and anti- depressants improve this by 15% on average. Keep this figure in your mind as we compare with other treatments. Unfortunately side-effects of drugs can be an issue. In particular they can cause a doubling to tripling of suicides in the first few weeks of use. Many find them addictive and difficult to stop.
Serotonin needs zinc to be effective. People with low zinc often do not respond to standard antidepressants for this reason. It is cheap and easy to supplement. Start at about 50 mg daily and reduce to 15mg daily after 3-6 months.
Folic acid and other B vitamins are also beneficial in depression and a multi-B vitamin supplement is often useful. Chromium also has a beneficial effect in depression. This is perhaps not surprising as it protects against hypoglycaemia.
Serotonin and Noradrenaline
You might well ask why serotonin gets low in the first place. To make serotonin you need the right building blocks in your food. You need tryptophan which is then converted to 5 hydroxytryptophan (5HT) and then converted to serotonin. The most logical way to treat depression is to provide the building blocks of serotonin and this has been tried. Trytophan is not available but 5 Hydoxytryptophan is and there have been 11 double-blind trials of 5HT in depression and these have shown improvements on the HRS scale of between 13 – 61%, but mostly around 30-40%. 5HT has been found to have a greater effect on depression, anxiety and sleep disturbance than SSRI drugs. More importantly, side-effects were much less. Most studies have used 300mg daily of 5 hydroxytrytophan. However lower doses such as 50mg twice daily will often help. It is said to give a “lying on the beach” feeling. It is also good for sleep problems. Unfortunately it cannot be prescribed but is available from some health food stores. It is relatively expensive.
Another solution is to eat foods which are high in tryptophan. Trytophan used to be uses in doses of 500 to 2000mg daily. These levels are not too hard to achieve with food. Cashew nuts are particularly rich in tryptophan (470mg per 100 grams as are pumpkin seeds (560mg per 100 grams). Most 100 gram portions of nuts and beans have about half this amount. Other good sources are dates and figs, eggs and Cheddar and Parmesan cheeses.
Low noradrenalin is thought to be a cause of depression, especially depression linked with lack of motivation. The building blocks for this are L phenylalanine and L-tyrosine. These amino acids have been tested in depression and found to work as well as standard anti-depressants but without the side-effects. The normal dose of tyrosine is between 1 and 2 grams daily and for L – phenylalanine the dose is between 500mg and 3 grams daily. Tyrosine is supposed to give a “world beater” or “on top of the world” feeling. These can be obtained from some health food stores. Amino acids are better taken away from meals.
However the majority of people have enough L phenylalanine on board but are unable to convert it to noradrenaline due to deficiency of Vitamin C. Using Vitamin C in large doses is often a cheap and effective way to improve levels of noradrenaline (see Vitamin C leaflet and aim at several grams a day).
Beware of Chemicals
A further factor in depression in some people is chemicals and it is worth considering this possibility. Ninety per cent of chemicals alter brain chemicals such as serotonin. People working with pesticides have higher rates of both depression and suicide and 50% of those exposed to solvents at work suffered from depression in one study. Air fresheners have been linked with depression and it is a good idea to avoid aerosols wherever possible. Chemicals from aerosols are absorbed directly into the brain where they interfere with normal brain function. The general rule here is to use as few chemicals as possible, especially those that smell.
Another important way of improving depression is exercise. A study of people with depression who exercised for 30-60 minutes 3-5 times weekly found a 30% improvement on the HRS scale. Exposure to daylight also helps. Note that both exercise and sunlight are known to increase serotonin levels. Exercise has many other benefits apart from improving mood, including reducing your risk of heart disease, stroke and cancer.
Some herbs can be helpful. St John’s wort at a dose of 300 – 900mg (standardised to 0.3% hypericin) has been shown to help in mild depression. It is prescribed by doctors in Germany and is easy to obtain from health food stores. Eight trials have shown it to be as effective as anti-depressants and with less side effects.
People sometimes ask me whether it is better to use herbs, drugs or nutrients for various conditions. Where they work equally well my answer is very simple – use the safest. Nutrients (vitamins, minerals, essential fats) are natural to the body and side-effects are rare. There have never been any deaths recorded from using these. Herbs are also natural substances but unlike nutrients they are not natural to the body. They have a good safety record but serious side-effects occasionally occur, especially with Chinese herbs. Pharmaceutical drugs have an important role to play but they are neither natural substances nor natural to the body. They generally work by blocking one of the body’s key biochemical pathways. Side-effects are commonplace and correctly prescribed drugs are responsible for 10,000 deaths annually in the UK (three times more deaths than road accidents). For this reason they needed to be treated with a degree of caution.
Finally it should be said that nutrition is only one approach to depression. Often it is necessary to look at the underlying causes and thought patterns. We also have a leaflet on thinking processes that deals with this issue.