Irritable Bowel Syndrome
(and related conditions)
Irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) is common, affecting about 1 in 5 of us. The name is a clue and tells us that something is making the bowel irritable. Our job is to find out what. This can sometimes lead to a cure (see below).
Typical symptoms are abdominal cramps accompanied by changes in bowel movements (usually diarrhea but sometimes constipation) or changes in the appearance of the stool. Clues are rushing to the toilet after eating food and relief of abdominal cramps after a bowel movement. There is nearly always wind or bloating.
Conventional treatment is with anti-spasmodic treatment (to ease the cramps) and medication to regulate bowel movements. This helps but is unsatisfactory in the long term as it does nothing to deal with the underlying causes.
The commonest cause of IBS is food intolerance. Milk, grains, yeast, corn, eggs and sugar can all trigger IBS. The most likely food to trigger IBS is wheat (symptoms after eating cereals or bread should raise suspicion). Milk is the second most likely. Some people are intolerant to several foods.
A clue to food intolerance is if you crave a certain food or eat it a lot. Eating the same food every day makes food intolerance more likely.
The best way to check for this is with an exclusion diet. Usually this means doing the Stone age diet (see food intolerance leaflet for details). It is a challenging diet but doesn’t take long. If symptoms settle after one week on this diet you will know that food is the cause. Then you need to add in foods one at a time. This will tell you which food is triggering the symptoms.
Other ways to test for food intolerance are blood tests like ALCAT (see Allergy leaflet for details) but these are expensive, not available on the NHS and not as accurate as an exclusion diet.
The other main food-related strategy is the FODMAPs diet. This is the best strategy if you react more to do fruit and vegetables and get a lot of wind. 86% of patients with IBS improve on a FODMAPs diet. The leaflet “the FODMAPs diet” tells you which foods to avoid. These are foods which can ferment and cause wind. There’s lots of them. I would suggest starting by removing the FODMAPs foods which you commonly eat and see if the IBS improves and only remove all the FODMAPs foods if this isn’t enough. Usually some of these will cause much worse reactions than others. You need to work out which ones.
The FODMAPs diet gives us a dilemma. Many of the vegetables are prebiotics which help provide breeding conditions for good bacteria. They include leeks, onion, garlic, artichokes and asparagus. I would suggest reducing these only if they give definite symptoms. This should not be a long-term diet as it could damage gut health over time by reducing good bacteria.
FODMAPs foods are not the only problem. Sugar alcohols can cause symptoms too. These are used as artificial sweeteners, sometimes in products labelled “no added sugar”. They include xylitol, sorbitol, mannitol and maltitol. They are also found in chewing gum. They can cause cramps, gas, bloating and diarrhoea.
In the majority of cases, IBS will resolve with the above but it can get more complicated. There are two conditions which overlap with IBS. These are dysbiosis and increased intestinal permeability (known as leaky gut). In fact in one study a third of people with food intolerance developed fungal dysbiosis over a two year period and about a third of those with fungal dysbiosis developed food intolerances.
Neither condition is well understood. Neither is likely to be recognized or treated by mainstream medicine.
Dysbiosis simply means abnormal gut bacteria. This occurs when the numbers of good bacteria decrease and when the harmful bacteria and fungi increase. This can make a big difference to our health as friendly bacteria are responsible for 85% of our immunity and also produce vitamins, proteins, neurotransmitters like serotonin and melatonin (responsible for out mood and our sleep), compounds that protect us against cancer and can break down toxic chemicals
Unfortunately dysbiosis is all too common today as harmful bacteria and fungi multiply quickly on diets high in sugar and refined foods, after taking medicine like antibiotics, the pill or proton pump inhibitors (stomach acid blockers).
Good bacteria breed in the large intestine and need plenty of fibre (especially from vegetables). A good diversity of gut bacteria is essential for a healthy gut. Eating a wide variety of vegetables, herbs (and low sugar) fruits, will build a healthy gut flora. Using probiotics, having fermented foods like kefir, sourdough and sauerkraut and avoiding sugar will also help. There are some specialized tests for gut flora (see gut fermentation leaflet for more details).
The commonest type of dysbiosis is fungal dysbiosis (this used to be called the candida syndrome but other fungi can be involved and fungal dysbiosis is a better name). The symptoms are similar to IBS with cramps, bloating, changes of bowel habit, brain fag and food (especially sugar) craving. Anal itching can be a more specific feature. Another clue is frequent fungal infections like vaginal or oral thrush. Another symptom to look out for is worsening of symptoms with sugar or alcohol.
Fungi live off sugar so starving them of sugar with a low sugar and low refined carbohydrate diet is an essential first step. Yeasty foods such as blue and mouldy cheeses such as brie can cause problems as can yeasty foods such as marmite, bread, vinegar (contained in ketchup and salad dressings), alcohol and mushrooms. Fruits can be taken in moderation but avoid dried fruits, overripe, tropical or sweet-tasting fruits and fruit juices.
On this diet improvement should occur with a month but the diet typically needs to be continued for 3 to 6 months. Sometimes antifungal medication like fluconazole is needed. Herbs and nutrients like caprylic acid, oregano oil, p’au d’arco will help. . Rotate these to get best results. Probiotics are also useful.
The gut membrane can get damaged by allergic reactions to food, by harmful bacteria and fungi, food intolerance, gluten intolerance and drugs such as non-steroid anti-inflammatory drugs (like ibuprofen). Emulsifiers in processed food which destroy the protective mucus than lines the gut are another factor.
When enough damage occurs, holes appear in the gut membrane, allowing toxic substances into the body. This includes the highly inflammatory lipopolysaccharides (LPS). This may lead to fatigue and brain fag and trigger auto-immune reactions, (even from friendly bacteria that migrate outside the gut, hence the name leaky gut (or intestinal permeability). There are some specialized tests for leaky gut. If IBS is severe then you can be fairly sure that leaky gut is present. I would normally recommend taking L glutamine 500mg three times daily before meals and butyric acid 500mg three times daily after meals if this should happen. Some probiotic can help with leaky gut (see Probiotic Leaflet).
Many people with IBS notice worsening of their symptoms when under stress and some cases of IBS have resolved with therapies like hypnosis. However usually there are other factors as well (as above) and it is best to use an approach that deals with all the causative factors.
If IBS starts suddenly after an episode of gastro-enteritis or a course of antibiotics I would suspect dysbiosis.
In one study patients given preventative antibiotics before surgery developed 6 times as much IBS as those not given it.
When IBS starts after a trip to a tropical country there may be another cause. This includes giadiasis (see below), worms and parasites which can also trigger IBS-like symptoms.
Could it be Something Else?
There are several conditions that can closely mimic IBS.
If the symptoms are severe or atypical then you will need investigation. Symptoms such as bloody diarrhoea, weight loss, nocturnal diarrhoea and rectal bleeding will warrant further investigation.
Inflammatory Bowel Disease
This is a key illness to rule out and includes Crohn’s disease and ulcerative colitis especially if symptoms are severe. A blood test for inflammatory markers (CRP, ESR) and a stool test for calprotectin will usually this rule out as it will be raised in inflammatory bowel disease (although raised levels in those over 40 can have other causes).
This illness is important as once it is fully treated the “IBS” can be cured. It mimics all the symptoms of IBS such as diarrhoea (sometimes constipation), abdominal cramps, wind and bloating, offensive stools, nausea (and sometimes vomiting). It can lead to food intolerances. (Other organisms can cause symptoms mimicking IBS including Cystospora cayetanesis –often found in Nepal and Cystisospora Belli)
Worsening at night (when the protozoa is more active) can be a clue as can jelly-like stools. Other symptoms can be low energy, headaches and a metallic taste.
It is probably responsible for a much bigger proportion of IBS cases than most doctors recognise. Although tropical travel can be a factor, most cases do not involve this. It can be caught from pets, animals and from children (who have a higher incidence). People who use acid-blocking medicines are more vulnerable,
The best way of picking up is to have three stool samples done for ova and parasites (one sample will only pick up 50-70% whereas three picks up 90% of infections). The ELISA immunosorbent test for giardia in the stools (where available) will accurately pick it up.
It is commonly treated with metronidazole or tinidazole but the herb wormwood may be the most effective treatment. Usually these will cure it. However re-infection is common if other members of the family carry the condition.
Coeliac disease and non-coeliac gluten sensitivity
These can present with symptoms similar to IBS (5% of those with typical IBS symptoms have coeliac disease). The symptoms of coeliac disease include diarrhoea or constipation, nausea, vomiting, wind, fatigue, weight loss and anaemia. A blood test will usually exclude this illness. Non-coeliac gluten sensitivity can cause similar symptoms: diarrhoea or vomiting, abdominal cramps, wind, fatigue, joint pain and headaches. This condition can be difficult to exclude with standard blood tests. Both these problems are getting much more common (see gluten leaflet).
Marked abdominal swelling and bloating can be a feature of ovarian cancer. Bowel and urinary symptoms and back pain can also occur in this condition. It may need to be ruled out (usually with a scan and blood test).
Bile Acid Diarrhoea
About 10% of people diagnosed with IBS really have bile acid diarrhoea. This can also present with abdominal pain, wind and diarrhoea. Deficiency of Vitamin B12 can occur. Usually the diarrhoea is more frequent than in IBS and can occur at night and the stools are often foul-smelling, pale and difficult to flush away. It can be diagnosed with the SeHCAT test (not widely available) or a trial on cholestyramine, colestipol or colesevelam.
Small Intestinal Bowel Overgrowth Syndrome (SIBO)
Another condition which closely mimics IBS is SIBO. This happens when the normally sterile small intestine gets colonized by bacteria or fungi. It is thought to be common but is difficult to diagnose, partly because many of the most useful tests are either not available on the NHS or there is limited access to them (they are mainly breath tests). The result is it is under-diagnosed. See Gut Fermentation leaflet for diagnosis and treatment of SIBO.
This condition also causes abdominal cramps, diarrhoea or constipation, wind and bloating. The latter symptoms can be marked.
High sugar diets and refined foods predispose to SIBO. Another major cause is the widespread prescription of PPIs (acid-blocking drugs such as omeprazole and lansoprazole). These drugs remove the acid which protects the small intestine from invasion by bacteria. A further factor is stomach acid declines as we age making SIBO more likely.
If pain is always in the same place I would be wary of diagnosing IBS and would suggest further investigation.
The mainstay of treatment of IBS is removing the dietary triggers. Removing sugar and refined carbohydrates from the diet, using probiotics and adding fermented foods can be useful strategies.
Some supplements are useful. Silicol gel is a widely available supplement which supports the thick mucus layer which protects the gut lining. It also helps to remove harmful substances. Trials suggest it reduces the severity of symptoms by half. Aloe vera juice is often helpful.
Deficiency of Vitamin D is common in irritable bowel (78% of patients) and this can harm the ability of gut bacteria to produce other vitamins, notably B5. Supplementing Vitamin D has not yet been shown to help IBS but I would suggest having it checked and taking at least 2000iu daily. Vitamin A and B5 help support a healthy gut and pantethine helps fight fungal infections. Digestive enzymes may also be useful. There are other supplements which help but this is outside the scope of this leaflet.